Historic night for Middletown City Council as three members, mayor sworn in

Municipal Court Judge James Sherron administered oaths of office in front of packed chambers.
The new Middletown City Council will hold its first meeting at 5:30 p.m. Jan. 2, 2024 in Council Chambers. From left, Jennifer Burg, Paul Horn, Elizabeth Slamka, Steve West II and Zack Ferrell. RICK McCRABB/STAFF

The new Middletown City Council will hold its first meeting at 5:30 p.m. Jan. 2, 2024 in Council Chambers. From left, Jennifer Burg, Paul Horn, Elizabeth Slamka, Steve West II and Zack Ferrell. RICK McCRABB/STAFF

MIDDLETOWN — The three newest City Council members and mayor got their first taste of being in the spotlight during a historic swearing-in ceremony Tuesday night in Council Chambers that was administered by Middletown Municipal Court Judge James Sherron.

For the first time in city history, four members, or 80% of council, were sworn in together. Typically, depending on the election cycle, either two or three members take the oath of office.

All four — mayor-elect Elizabeth Slamka and council members Jennifer Carter, Paul Horn and Steve West II — talked about the city’s future and their plans during their remarks.

Slamka, Carter and West II were elected on Nov. 7, and Horn, a Middletown businessman, was selected by City Council to fill the two-year, unexpired term when Rodney Muterspaw resigned his seat in November due to family health issues.

Since Mayor Nicole Condrey, Vice Mayor Monica Thomas and council member Tal Moon didn’t seek re-election this year, and with Muterspaw resigning, only Zack Ferrell, who was elected two years ago, remained on council.

The new council will hold its first meeting at 5:30 p.m. Jan. 2.

Council Chambers were packed Tuesday night with city of Middletown officials, community leaders and family and friends of the new council members.

Jennifer Carter is sworn-in Tuesday night as a Middletown City Council member by Municipal Court Judge James Sherron. Her husband, William, holds the Bible. RICK McCRABB/STAFF

icon to expand image

After being sworn in, Carter, who was accompanied by her husband, William, was succinct in her comments: “Let’s get to work. All of us.”

Paul Horn is sworn-in Tuesday night as a Middletown City Council member by Municipal Court Judge James Sherron. His girlfriend, Maureen Schumacker, holds the Bible. RICK McCRABB/STAFF

icon to expand image

Horn said Middletown enjoyed “a boom” in the 1970s, and he believes the city is positioned for another growth spurt. For that to happen, he said, the city needs to offer more affordable housing and embrace innovation by providing electric vehicle charging stations.

Steve West II is sworn-in Tuesday night as a Middletown City Council member by Municipal Court Judge James Sherron. His son, Christopher, 11, holds the Bible. RICK McCRABB/STAFF

icon to expand image

West II said he was “very grateful and humbled” to be elected, and he called serving on council “a big responsibility to represent the citizens.”

Elizabeth Slamka is sworn-in Tuesday night as Middletown mayor by Municipal Court Judge James Sherron. RICK McCRABB/STAFF

icon to expand image

Slamka, who defeated Joe Mulligan for the mayor’s seat, thanked her campaign team and her family for their support. She called being mayor “a lifelong dream” that came to fruition.

The Cornell University graduate has visited 22 countries and speaks two languages, but she said it’s not about her.

“It’s about you,” she said, before adding that all public officials “work for the people. All the people.”

About the Author